After the WWDC24 conference, Musk posted several consecutive pieces of content on the X platform accusing Apple of "selling out user data." He said, "If Apple integrates OpenAI at the OS level, Apple devices will be banned from my company." He argued that Apple is not smart enough to ensure that OpenAI protects the security and privacy of its users.
Musk is at odds with OpenAI. He was one of the founders of OpenAI but resigned from the board of directors in 2018 and has expressed dissatisfaction with the direction of OpenAI. In addition, Musk has also clashed with Apple. In 2022, he had accused Apple of threatening to take Twitter off its app store.

Why did Musk accuse Apple of "selling user data"?

Musk accused Apple of "selling user data" for several reasons:

DATA SECURITY ISSUES: Musk believes that Apple's partnership with OpenAI to integrate ChatGPT into Apple devices could lead to data security issues as user data is collected and shared with third parties.
Privacy protection issue: Musk has always emphasized the importance of privacy protection, and he believes that Apple should develop AI on its own instead of working with OpenAI because it can better protect the privacy of its users.
Mistrust of OpenAI: Musk is at odds with OpenAI, having been one of its founders but later leaving the organization and expressing dissatisfaction with its direction. He believes that OpenAI may utilize user data for commercial purposes rather than for the benefit of the users.

Although Apple has said it will take steps to protect user data security and privacy, Musk doesn't seem to be buying it. His accusations have also raised concerns about data security and privacy protection. When using any technology product, users should be concerned about their data security and privacy protection and take appropriate measures to protect their rights.

Is Musk's accusation that Apple "sells user data" legally valid?

Musk's accusation that Apple "sells user data" has no solid legal basis.

According to Apple's statement, they take a number of measures to protect the security and privacy of user data when using ChatGPT, including optionally asking for user consent when enabling the ChatGPT feature and only sending data needed for queries. In addition, Apple states that they do not have access to user data and that data is discarded after results are generated and sent to the user.

However, Musk's concerns about Apple's partnership with OpenAI also reflect some users' concerns about data privacy and security. Data privacy and security is an important issue in the tech sector, and requires a concerted effort to ensure that users' rights are protected.

If Musk believes that Apple's behavior violates the law, he can resolve the dispute through legal channels. But without sufficient evidence, mere accusations through social media do not constitute a legal basis.

It is very important for users to protect the security and privacy of their personal data. When using any technology product or service, users should read the relevant privacy policy and terms of use carefully to understand how their data will be used and protected. At the same time, users can also take measures to enhance their data security, such as setting up strong passwords, regularly updating software, and paying attention to preventing online fraud.